The September Music Project
A Plea for Help
As should be obvious, this is just my first swipe at a plan.
All thoughts, emendations, and additions are welcome.
Overview
The improv troupe has a ton of musicians who don't have an effective outlet for their musical creativity. Lately I've heard several people talking about how it would be cool if some of us wrote music together, or if we had a band, et cetera, et cetera.
These are really talented people, but nothing ever comes of it.
So: by September 3rd, I want to sketch out a project for our getting together and creating some sort of music throughout the month of September.
It should have a clearly defined, tenable goal.
The goal should be limited enough so that the SMP doesn't become onerous for the participants.
- To that end, it should be over in a month.
- We should end up with some final lasting product that we can (theoretically) be proud of.
- It should not emphasize having fun, not perfectionism.
Things the SMP Should Accomplish Musically
Songwriting
We can all write songs. There's no way to self-efface out of this one; we've all improvised songs during Micetro.
However, we never quite seem to get around to writing them properly.
I think there's just not enough incentive for us. All of the venues for creative output are too high-pressure. There aren't any deadlines, so writing music becomes just one more thing that we can always work on... later....
Also, we have no infrastructure for getting feedback from our peers about our work.
Performance
Everybody in the troupe wants to be in a band. But being in a band requires finding people to be in a band with. This can be especially hard if most of your social contacts are in a large engineering company filled with men who have long conversations about lawn edging. Not that I'm bitter. Anyway, we need a good chance to perform music together.
Recording
As one might infer from the DoItYourselfMusic page, I have a small amount of recording equipment: an SM57 mic, a
POD, a small mixer, a couple guitars, a good MIDI trigger, and a fast computer with an okay sequencer. It's enough to record home demos with. Many of us can write decent songs and play decently, but we don't even have a chance to get at a 4-track.
Ideally, the SMP will allow us to pool our equipment and do some decent recording.
Bob can contribute two guitars (electric; a Strat and a Gibson), a bass, a couple pedals (distortion, flanger, bass chorus), and a few amps (Peavey !MicroBass
and a Fender Princeton Chorus)
I've been writing my own music, with my little setup, knowing full well that my songwriting is no great shakes. However, every time I've written a song, I've learned a tremendous amount about recording. I hope that more opportunities to put together little demos allow me to gain more experience with the setup. Ideally, everybody involved would learn something about digital recording.
So,
what is it? (Our "Mission Statement.")
Kacey, Amy, Bob, and Peter will get together and form a 'provisional band.' We'll collectively write and record a few songs, and perform one of them at No Shame.
(Ideally, the songs should not be that good. :) 1
)
We'll finish all of this by the end of the month.
"The Future, Conan?"
I have long-term plans here.
I can see this scaling up to something similar to Shannon's "Under the Gun" project for
No Shame Theatre. For reference, this is where Shannon gathers together 21 actors, 7 writers, 7 directors, and a bunch of slips of paper with words on them. On Monday, he divvys everybody up into groups (1 writer, 1 director, 3 actors each). Each group has to come up with a 5-minute skit by Friday.
Why not have an analogous thing for music?
We could invite more musicians in on this, do the random groupings, and come up with music for public performance -- either for playing at
No Shame Theatre, or doing an entire music-showcase of what we've all come up with.
--
That said, there's some issues with involving more people.
First off, my little ersatz recording studio doesn't scale. That, and I'm not sure I trust just anybody to not, say, spill a Coke on my $200
POD. That, and if we have seven bands clamoring for studio time, I can't play studio rat for all of them.
At any rate, I'd like to settle doing this with just us in September, then maybe bringing in another four people in October and maybe mix up the groups, and then scale up further if our efforts are successful.
On Planning Ahead -- What to Do the Rest of This Month (August)
(Peter): I myself don't have any plans musically for the rest of August. I'm pretty solidly busy until the 24th. That said, there are still some things we can do this month:
Write Music:
It couldn't hurt to toy with writing stuff, or collate and organize what we've already written, and bring some ideas in for September.
Schedule:
Figure out where and when we'll meet for a low-key jam session (see below).
Learn One Another's Background:
I'd like to figure out what kind of musical style each of us has -- to that end, I made a page for "Damn, I Wish I Had Written That".
Predict & Solve Performance Problems:
Mainly, we have to deal with our Curious Lack of Drummer. These are the options as I see it:
- Record a drum track, and use it in the performance. (Hey, it worked for
They Might Be Giants....) - Bring a drum machine to the performance. (Probably more like a laptop with MIDI.)
- Track down a drummer & rope in said drummer.
- ???
The other thing to think about is, what's the best way to take advantage of Kacey's mad violin skillz?
- Go the Dave Matthews Band route -- have the violin basically reinforce the guitar chords, but veer off into soloing at every opportunity.
- I went to the Belle & Sebastian concert not too long ago, and they have one song with a simple trumpet riff after the chorus. Every time the trumpeter stepped up to the mic, he got wild applause from the audience. I wonder if we can use the violin in a similar crowd-pleasing way.
My favorite option is to move away from straight-ahead pop music. I can easily envision us doing a sort of languid swing number. 2
I could capo my guitar way up, get it mostly out of the violin's frequency range, and use it in a more percussive, mandolin-like way. Kacey could provide a backing melody for Amy, and occasionally solo.- Going country is another, similar option.
- We need to keep in mind the range of sounds a violin (and, presumably, Kacey) can produce. XTC's "Grass" (from Skylarking) alternates its violin between a pizzicato melody (for the verses) and an arco melody (for the chorus) to great effect.
Covers!
Amy suggested we try a doing some covers. Sounds like a great way to get up to speed together musically. In the interest of democracy, I think we should all suggest one song. This gives us four songs to try to cover, which should be more than enough to keep us occupied for the month.
- Peter's Suggestion: "New York City." Originally by Cub, covered by
They Might Be Giants. Most of us seem to like it, it has a straight-ahead chord structure, and I suspect the tubular-bell melody line from the
TMBG version could be translated to violin.
Detailed Plans for September
Songwriting
Meet for a while to just freely play. Ideally we pick favorite tunes out of that.
Once we have a fair-enough tune, we work on bringing that up to speed, playing it together.
Then, we all have a go at improvising lyrics to it. Ideally, we take down bits and pieces of what works until we have a fair little song. 3
Performing
Then we practice performing however many songs we get for a while. (Note that we shouldn't make a very technically demanding song, or it will require endless rehearsal :) ).
Pick one that we like, and perform it at No Shame, which should be mid-month or so. (Working on getting the date from Shannon.)
We ought to consider what kind of music would play well to the crowd at No Shame -- I'd like us to not be self-indulgent.
Recording
After No Shame, we have a go at recording. 4
First, pile up lots of recording equipment 5
and dump it at either Bob's house or Peter's apartment.
Then, we have a long 'studio day' or two (at most) 6
where we twiddle knobs, set up microphones, and pretend to be studio rats for a while.
The key is to keep recording on a brisk, reasonable schedule. 7
First, get a crappy copy of the song recorded and laid down. Then, work on improving it, replacing the worst tracks with better recordings.
We allot a specific amount of time to recording, and once we're done, we're done, whether our song could be improved with zealous re-editing or not. By the end of recording day #2, I would much rather have a crappy copy of a completed song than an exquisite recording that isn't finished. 8
Finally, burn CD's, create spiffy cover art, give them as gifts to friends and family. :)
Our Schedule!
August 26th: First meeting. Practice.
Things to do:
- I think we should divide our time between trying out covers and instrumental jamming around simple chord progressions.
- We just need to get comfortable playing together, and get over the 'ick' factor.
- Maybe we'll come out of it with a few scraps of melody and/or lyrics that we can mull over until the next meeting.
To do before then:
- Think about what covers we want to try.
- Gather up any stuff that you've already written that you want to work on.
- ???
Recommended Reading
Songwriting
The Craft and Business of Songwriting, by John Braheny- This is one of the best books to truly analyze the craft of songwriting. There are excellent chapters which discuss hooks, song structure and other key elements of hit songs. Braheny is the Co-Founder of the Los Angeles Songwriters Showcase, and is well regarded by many songwriters.
- (Peter): I'm checking this one out at the library right now...
88 Songwriting Wrongs and How to Right Them, by Pat & Pete Luboff- When someone tells you how to write a song, the correct and appropriate reaction is to poke that person in the eye. In 88 Songwriting Wrongs, though, the Luboffs offer the kind of knowledge that songwriters would otherwise need years to learn on their own. A few "wrongs" - like "Don't be intentionally obscure" - are indeed subjective calls, but the majority contain advice traceable to the output of top songwriters. Written in a casual, conversational tone (the perceived vernacular of musicians), the book starts with rhyme schemes and song forms and moves on to demo tips, pitching a package and finally "Coping With Success." May you all need to read that far. -Rich Maloof
Songwriters on Songwriting, by Paul Zollo- If you want to read what the most revered songwriters in pop have to say about their life's work, you've hit pay dirt. Paul Zollo's book collects interviews with the biggest guns of the past 30-odd years, including (big breath?) Todd Rundgren, Bob Dylan, Bruce Cockburn, Neil Young, Burt Bacharach, Laura Nyro, R.E.M., Frank Zappa, Leonard Cohen, Paul Simon and many others. Though the interviews often drift off topic, Zollo probes these creative minds with scientific fascination. Aspiring songwriters may still sense a gap - you're not going to learn how to write a song by reading a book - but there's far more interest here than in the pap tucked into newsstand magazines. As Zappa says in an interview from 1987, "There's no glamour to doing the laborious job of developing a personal theory of harmony or a personal feel for how you want rhythm to function in your work." -Rich Maloof
Practicing With Your Band
- (haven't found anything)
Performance
- (haven't found anything)
Home-Studio Recording
- Check out the wiki's DoItYourselfMusic page.
- (need to find books)
Useful Links
- The
Austin Songwriters' Group. Contests, critique sessions, songwriters' showcases, et cetera.
National Novel-Writing Month. Nothing to do with music, but everything to do with producing a substantial piece of work (in this case, a 50,000-word novel), that is not necessarily that good, inside of a month.
Footnotes
1
God knows, we don't need that kind of pressure.
2
Think Riders in the Sky (they do almost all the music for
Pixar's movies and shorts) at half speed.
3
(Peter): Odds are, songwriting will be a lot more free-form & organic. I'm just really cowed by writing lyrics, and this is the order of events that is the least intimidating to me personally. Really, if there's a method to this, we'll all probably discover it together. <sigh> :)
4
As mid-September rolls around, I'll need to figure out how much Kacey & Amy want to be involved in the recording process. In my experience, recording demos is 10% singing/playing, and (somehow) 140% twiddling knobs, dealing with emotionally unstable computers, trying different MIDI instruments, and adjusting levels and post-effects. I know I would be up for doing this for two days straight, and I suspect Bob would be okay with it, but Amy & Kacey may prefer to just do their time on the mics and be done with it.
5
We might consider getting our hands on some slightly better recording equipment. For instance, a proper condenser mic might be useful. Susie's Brian may be able to lend us instruments for a couple of days.
6
We want to do this in as few sessions as possible, because getting everything up and getting ourselves ready to go takes a lot of time.
7
I need to plan our 'studio' time so that we work efficiently. It'll help to have our song cheated out on MIDI first, and to know exactly what we need to record. Maybe we can get various members'o'the band around at different times to record their stuff. I'm just worried that we'll get (say) Kacey standing around for an hour while I try to get the perfect lead vocal track from (say) Amy. Recording sessions have to move.
8
At the very least, we need to get audio recorded. Once the audio data is on the computer, I could just do the mixing and post-effects on my own. Not that I would do that(thoughts of Brian Wilson running the Pet Sounds sessions with an iron fist deter me); I'm just saying at that point we don't need all of these people and all of this equipment to get to a finished product.
4 pages link to PSRSeptemberMusicProject:




